In Garrett County, these are some of our preferred dining establishments. The ambiance is even more delightful, and the selection is astonishing. They offer options that cater to every member of the family, from small, family-owned establishments to upscale dining experiences. Exploring Deep Creek Lake is not just about enjoying the numerous and thrilling attractions throughout the year, but also indulging in delectable eateries.
Run by the son of Evelyn and “Ace” Helmuth, the original owners and developers of Wisp Resort, Martin’s has become well-known around the lake for its stunning lake views and delicious cuisine. They offer catering carry-out and catering pickup, as well as dine-in options. The menu features the freshest food available, sourcing cheeses, meats, and vegetables locally to ensure a farm-to-table experience. The menu also changes seasonally to highlight the best of each season.
Location: 20160 Garrett Highway, Oakland, MD 21550.
Moonshadow
Moonshadow offers a variety of delicious flavors and spices in their menu, such as Wonton Tuna Tacos or Beefalo Chipotle Meatballs. They can cater to any dietary restrictions you may have with their wide range of options, including vegan and gluten-free options. You can enjoy a delicious meal inside the cozy and warm atmosphere, or if you prefer, they can deliver the great food to you. Additionally, you can receive free supplies for making s’mores from the RFID cards provided by the Resort Wisp. After a long day of skiing, you can unwind and relax at the firepits at Moonshadow while enjoying the scenic views.
Location: 145 Bumble Bee Rd in McHenry, across from the university, McHenry, MD 21520.
Dutch’s at Silver Tree
Come for the regular dinner and lunch menu or choose from their Friday night buffet. No matter what you get, you will love the atmosphere and service. Enjoy a nice appetizer of sea scallops or opt for the crab soup as your entree. Step inside and enjoy the warm, inviting rustic atmosphere. You can even host events and weddings at Dutch’s fine dining. Indulge in the best voted crab cakes on the lake at Dutch’s.
Location: 567 Glendale Road Oakland, MD 21550 Website: https://www.Restaurantji.Com/md/oakland/dutchs-at-silver-tree-restaurant-/.
Brenda’s Pizzeria
Brenda’s Pizzeria is open every day from 9 am to 11 pm and offers reasonably priced salads. They also have stuffed shells and pasta. If there is a picky eater in the group, they can get exactly what they want without sacrificing their favorite toppings. There is no need to decide on just one slice, you can buy your favorite pizza by the slice at Brenda’s.
Location: 21311 Garrett Hwy Trader’s Landing at Deep Creek Lake, Oakland, MD 21550-7206.
Pine Lodge Steakhouse
Browse around the gift shop or sit down in the beautiful dining room while the chefs prepare your meal. The house chefs take pride in their menu preparation to ensure that it meets their high-quality standards. No matter what, you will not be disappointed. Opt for a bit of surf and turf with crab cakes and filet, or enjoy a nice New York strip. The Pine Lodge Steakhouse is the perfect place for a wonderful meal, offering a menu bar for lunch and dinner.
Address: 1520 Deep Creek Drive, McHenry, Maryland 21541.
Canoe on the Run
Enjoy a variety of hearty fresh sandwiches and wraps. They offer a selection of hot chocolates and a variety of drinks ranging from lattes to chai. Choose between indoor or outdoor seating while grabbing a delicious breakfast. Whether you’re coming into town or leaving for the day, stop by for a delicious breakfast to energize you.
Location: 2622 Deep Creek Drive, McHenry, MD 21541-1422.
Englanders
This unique and beautiful restaurant has many items on display that will catch your eye in a minute as you walk in. The old school soda shop offers awesome service and plenty of traditional dinner food. Not only will you love the food, but you will also love purchasing antiques or looking at them. They have breakfast and sandwiches, as well as soup that everyone loves.
Location: 205 E Alder St, Oakland, MD 21550-1513+.
Honi- Honi Bar
You will have a great experience at this restaurant, whether you choose to sit down and enjoy some delicious food or grab a bucket of drinks. The atmosphere on the deck is heated and there is live music playing, creating a wonderful ambiance. You can also enjoy a few games of cornhole outside or sit inside. This is the perfect way to end a day on the lake, with both outdoor and indoor experiences available.
Location: 19745 Garrett Hwy, Oakland, MD 21550-7143.
El Canelo
There is something for everyone here, even the pickiest eaters, and the menu is large. The place is perfect for a family night, with a low-key atmosphere and clean, bright surroundings. Try out their homemade tacos, Chile Rellenos, or favorite Mexican dish. Enjoy a delicious Mexican fiesta at El Canelo.
Location: 12680 Garrett Highway, Oakland, MD 21550-1160.
Mountain State Brewing Co
Stop by and try their delicious woodfire pizza paired with a few of their local beers. This microbrewery is not only a great place for drinks, but they also offer delicious desserts and food. Make sure to try their Flatbread Nutella for a tasty treat. They have a variety of seasonal favorites as well as year-round options. The taproom and music hall offer live music and brewery tours. Don’t miss out on their dynamite pizza and delicious brews.
Location: 6690 Sang Run Road McHenry, Maryland.
Lakeside Creamery
If you are visiting Deep Creek Lake, be sure to check out their food truck. This location has a hot commodity for those staying in the area, which is the lakefront view. They offer fresh-made waffle cones, as well as classic cake and sugar cones. This homemade ice cream shop is all about customization, so you can create your favorite ice cream.
Location: 20282 Garrett Highway, Oakland, MD 21550.
Archie’s Barbeque
Come and visit this exceptional barbeque restaurant, which is operated and owned by a family. The overall experience and the quality of service prove to be exceptional. They also have a pet-friendly area and outdoor seating. Additionally, they have won awards for their BBQ. Make sure to try some of their specialty sandwiches or their smoked brisket. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the smoky flavor of their homemade BBQ while munching on great food.
Location: 25259 Garrett Highway McHenry, Maryland 21541.
Trader’s Coffee House
Ensure that you make a stop here while visiting for a pleasant breakfast. The coffee addicts here prioritize making a great cup of coffee for everyone, so be sure to bring them all a nice treat. Enjoy their delicious deli sandwiches and carefully crafted drinks, as well as a variety of delightful sweets. House Coffee Trader’s is the perfect place in town for a dozen hot chocolates and strong coffee.
Location: 21311 Garrett Hwy Oakland, MD 21550-7206.
It doesn’t matter where you decide to eat during your stay in the breathtaking Lake Creek Deep area. At Red Barn Vacations, their premium vacation rentals are centrally located, making it easy and quick for you to drive to a delicious restaurant. Whether you’re in the mood for a delightful pasta dish or some flavorful Mexican cuisine, you can find it all in Lake Creek Deep. We hope to see you soon, so you can enjoy the beautiful atmosphere and delicious food here at Creek Deep.