Our Pros Found the Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce Brands

Our Pros Found the Best Store-Bought Pizza Sauce Brands

Our Pros Found The Best Store Bought Pizza Sauce Brands

When it comes to making pizza at home, the sauce plays a crucial role in bringing all the flavors together. With so many pizza sauce brands available, our Test Kitchen took on the challenge of finding the best options. We carefully researched popular brands and conducted blind tastings to evaluate their flavor, texture, and appearance. After sampling numerous sauces on pizza crusts with a sprinkle of cheese, we selected the top four brands that stood out among the rest.

Flavor, Texture, and Appearance Criteria

Our Test Kitchen team evaluated each sauce based on the following criteria:

  • Flavor: Does the sauce taste of fresh tomatoes? Is it properly salted? What other herbs and spices have been added, and how do they taste? Is the sauce something you’d enjoy on pizza?
  • Texture: What is the texture of the sauce like? Is it smooth or a bit more rustic? Is it thick enough for spreading across pizza dough or is it a bit thinner like a marinara?
  • Appearance: While the sauce will be covered with cheese and toppings, our Test Kitchen still wanted a sauce that looked appetizing. Is the sauce tempting? Bright red? Are there any flecks of herbs or seasonings?

Best Pizza Sauce Overall: Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce

Rao’s Pizza Sauce In Jar, In Small Bowl, On Pizza

If you’re looking for a sauce that reminds you of the delicious offerings from your favorite fancy pizzeria, Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce is the top choice. Rao’s stood out among the nine other options in our blind tasting, offering a fresh and homemade taste that is hard to beat. The sauce had a distinct fresh tomato flavor, complemented by the perfect balance of oregano and garlic. What set Rao’s apart was the visible ingredients in the sauce, including a few tomato seeds, making it feel like a truly authentic homemade sauce. Additionally, our Test Kitchen team noted hints of olive oil, which added a great taste and texture to the sauce. Rao’s Homemade Pizza Sauce is a standout option that won’t get lost even with a great homemade crust and fresh mozzarella.

Best for Basil Fanatics: Classico Traditional Pizza Sauce

Classico Pizza Sauce In Jar, In Small Bowl And On Pizza Slices

If you’re a fan of Margherita pizza and can’t get enough basil, Classico Traditional Pizza Sauce is the perfect choice for your next pizza night. The sauce offers a thick and rich texture, with a deep red color that our Test Kitchen staff found appealing. What sets Classico apart is its herb-forwardness, with basil being the most prominent taste alongside the jammy tomato flavor. The sauce also strikes a perfect balance with oregano and black pepper. Classico Traditional Pizza Sauce requires no additional tweaks – simply pair it with a good pizza crust and start cooking.

Best Organic Option: Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce

Muir Glen Pizza Sauce In Can, Sin Small Bowl And On Pizza

If you prefer organic ingredients, Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce is an excellent choice. Packed with robust tomato flavor, this sauce gives the impression that it has been reduced slightly to enhance the taste of the produce. However, it doesn’t stop at tomatoes. Testers noticed a perfect balance of garlic, which adds depth to the overall flavor profile. Muir Glen’s pizza sauce is thicker than most, making it ideal for spreading across a homemade crust. If you value organic ingredients and a rich tomato taste, Muir Glen Organic Pizza Sauce is the way to go.

Best Plain Pizza Sauce: Pomi Pizza Sauce

Pomi Pizza Sauce In Can, In Small Bowl And On Pizza

For those who prefer a plain pizza sauce that serves as a great foundation for customization, Pomi Pizza Sauce is the perfect choice. This sauce offers a tangy tomato flavor that alone is exceptionally pleasing. It reminded testers of fresh Roma tomatoes from the garden. While the herbs in this sauce are milder compared to others, it works perfectly if you plan to layer on additional flavors or prefer to add fresh herbs from your garden. Pomi Pizza Sauce provides a blank canvas for your culinary creativity.

How to Use Store-Bought Pizza Sauce

While jarred pizza sauce is commonly associated with homemade pizza, its uses extend beyond that. Here are a few ideas to get creative with store-bought pizza sauce:

  • Homemade Pizza: Of course, the classic use for pizza sauce is to create your own homemade pizzas. Use one of our Test Kitchen-preferred brands as a base and add your favorite toppings.
  • Casseroles: Pizza sauce can be a flavorful addition to various casseroles. Incorporate it into dishes like baked ziti or lasagna for a twist of pizza-inspired taste.
  • Stromboli: Use pizza sauce as a dipping sauce for stromboli. The tangy flavor pairs well with the savory fillings.
  • Sloppy Joes: Give your Sloppy Joes a pizza twist by using pizza sauce as a base instead of the traditional tomato sauce. It adds extra depth of flavor to this classic sandwich.

With these versatile options, you can make the most out of your store-bought pizza sauce beyond just traditional pizza recipes.