Kemp Insurance Agency

The top insurance provider in Tuscarawas County.

Our Agents

Donald C Kemp

Donald C Kemp

Licensed representative since 1976, LUTCF certification.

Nathan D Kemp

Nathan D Kemp

Authorized broker since 2009.

Thomas J Andrews

Thomas J Andrews

Licensed agent since 1987, agricultural insurance agent.

Amy M Jones Headshot

Amy M Jones

Office supervisor, authorized personnel since 1989.

Connie Dula

Connie Dula

Certified personnel since 2020.

Our Carriers

We are proud to collaborate with the insurance providers listed below.

Why Choose Us?

If the customer is protected and satisfied, then we are satisfied. From the insurance viewpoint, the agent works for the customer, not the insurance companies. At Kemp Insurance Agency, we advocate for our customers. It is very straightforward.

Kemp Insurance Agency is here for you. We understand that dealing with insurance claims, changes, switches, etc. Can be confusing for the average person who does not deal with these issues regularly. That is why we are here to assist and guide our customers through any insurance-related process. We prioritize retaining our customers for life, and a crucial aspect of that is taking the time to listen to the insured’s needs and customizing coverage and services to meet or even surpass their expectations.

Your Dependable Local Insurance Agency

Our range of insurance options has grown and improved, incorporating numerous excellent providers, while still maintaining Nationwide as our primary provider. We transitioned into an independent insurance agency in July 2020. Nathan Kemp, Don’s son, joined the business in 2009, becoming a valuable addition to our multi-generational team. In 1993, Don acquired Dale Hill’s Nationwide agency, who was his mentor, when we expanded. Since 1986, we have been serving Tuscarawas and the surrounding counties. Don Kemp, our founder, left his position as a loan officer with Production Credit to establish Kemp Insurance Agency, a local Nationwide Insurance Agent in New Philadelphia.

Insurance Services

Family in front of house

Personal – Home & Auto Insurance

We offer a wide range of insurance options for your personal auto and property needs, including auto, home, and renter’s insurance coverage.

Cows in a field.

Farm Insurance

Insuring farms and their distinct individual coverage requirements is one of our specialties, encompassing everything from the largest grain operation to the smallest hobby farm and everything in between.

Contractor that needs Insurance.

Commercial Auto Insurance

We offer a wide range of competitive options from numerous carriers to cover all your commercial auto needs, including fleets, semis, heavy farm vehicles, dump trucks, and contractor vehicles.

Small Business owners standing in front of open sign

Business & Commercial Liability Insurance

We provide insurance for all types of commercial structures and businesses, including landlords, manufacturing, restaurants, and lessor’s risk. We have both the largest national carriers and reliable regional carriers to meet your specific needs, regardless of the size.

Construction workers ins a home.

Specialty Products Insurance

Coverages hard-to-find other many and flips/renos/homes new forage risk builder’s, (E&O) liability professional, bonds professional and commercial of types all offer We.

corn field

Crop Insurance

Our crop insurance agent, who has more than 30 years of experience, can customize your crop coverage and clarify each aspect and step in the process, along with the relevant government guidelines that are applicable to the coverage.


“Excellent individualized assistance, a wide range of insurance options, everyone I refer to Nate values the suggestion.”

Pete S.

Pete S.

Extremely effective and consistently very amiable! I have been associated with them for more than 50 years!!!

Dennis E.

Dennis E.

Extremely useful. Discovered a rate at a price considerably lower than what I was hoping to spend!

Amber B.

Amber B.